Mavrick_45's Avatar
156 Posts
17 years, 4 months ago
hmm they both had comic stips - they both had a cartoon show....

so......garfield (reson not specified)
    79987 Posts
    17 years, 4 months ago
    I would have to go with Heathcliff.
      TheWizard241's Avatar
      455 Posts
      17 years, 4 months ago
      Should we disregard the recent Garfield movie when we make this decision?
        15 Posts
        17 years, 4 months ago
        The Garfield movie sucked. Only Garfield was animated, and the other animals just had moving mouths. It was just strange that everyone had different voices after watching all those old episodes and TV specials as a kid. Live action wasn't the way to go.
          WARLORD1863's Avatar
          517 Posts
          17 years, 4 months ago
          GARFIELD BABY!
          You must enter a signature
            79987 Posts
            17 years, 4 months ago
            Heathcliff all the way! I also liked Garfield, but he was too lazy.
              865 Posts
              17 years, 4 months ago
              Comics or the show?

              For comics I say Garfield was funnier, and for shows I liked Heathcliff Better.
                SSJ_Jup81's Avatar
                4806 Posts
                17 years, 4 months ago
                Show wise, I preferred Heathcliffe to Garfield.

                Strip wise, I couldnt' say. I've only read some of the Heathcliffe comic strip once when I was visiting family in New York. We don't get it here. All we have is Garfield. I did like the Heathcliffe one, though.
                  79987 Posts
                  17 years, 4 months ago
                  garfeild - hands down
                    79987 Posts
                    17 years, 4 months ago

                    Anyway, I didn't know Heathcliff had a stripe. Cartoonwise, I remember Garfield a little better. Heathcliff does have a better theme song. I watched it several times on the site.
                      79987 Posts
                      17 years, 3 months ago
                      Its a shame that the voice of Garfield, a voice actor named Lorenzo Music, passed away......I haven't seen the movie but I imagine Bill Murrays laidback style could probably be a passable substitute...
                        Disney_Collector's Avatar
                        17 years, 3 months ago
                        to be honest this is a hard one cause they are so very different, so ill say none cause i like them both the same
                        Every time I visit RetroJunkit seems to change. Just glad the people dont.

                        Come on Vertex and Mod Gang, sort out my contributions :lol:
                          79987 Posts
                          17 years, 3 months ago
                          Definitely Garfield, I was never really a fan of Heathcliff. Speaking of Garfield movies though...I love the Garfield Christmas special...I watch that year round :lol:
                            dxterp's Avatar
                            72 Posts
                            16 years ago
                            out of garfield and heathcliff, who do you think is the best cat?

                            personally, i love both. but if i had to choose, its heathcliff all the way.
                            His attitude is awesome. Do not get me wrong, garfields attitude is cool, too. i love it when he kicks odie off the tables.

                            but heacliff, man, no one beats him.

                            I would say Heathcliff....that was a much better show
                              Edymnion's Avatar
                              2304 Posts
                              16 years ago
                              anybody with Cleo on his arm is ahead of the game in my book!

                              Out of the choices available though, it depends on what you mean. I would rather have Garfield as a pet, but I'd rather watch/read about Heathcliff.

                                358 Posts
                                16 years ago
                                I like Garfield more, but of the 2 cartoons Heathcliff was better cause I didn't like the farm crap on Garfield.
                                  16 years ago
                                  I liked Garfield, Heathcliff was too much of a pimp for me, and he's also lazy like me.

                                  Garfield--I did like both when I was young, but since I haven't seen Heathcliff in years, and Garfield has remained a part of my life--so Garfield it is.

                                  And yes, I liked the movie! Okay?!!!!!!! I even OWN it!!!!!!!

                                  Allison :-)
                                  "Hey, do you know me? I ran for president in 1984. I got stomped like a narc at a biker rally."--Dennis Miller if Walter Mondale made an American Express commercial(1988)
                                    3931 Posts
                                    16 years ago
                                    my vote goes to Heathcliff. He used to kill all of the dogs who challenged him. Garfield gets spanked all the time. The only thing he does is pick on his mentally challenged puppy.

                                    ITS TRUE!
                                      pikachulover's Avatar
                                      2944 Posts
                                      16 years ago
                                      I don't know I like them both Garfeild had a girl too. He had Arlene.
                                        51 Posts
                                        16 years ago
                                        Heathcliff was gangsta but Garfield was funny as hell. I vote for Garfield. By the way, was anybody slightly freaked out by the Garfield Halloween special as a kid?
                                          An unhandled error has occurred. Reload Dismiss