Im talking showmanship, character, speaking skills, personality, etc
I would go with;
1.Hulk Hogan- Not one of my favorite Wrestler's of all-time and if you are talking about just wrestling, he sucks. That being said, this guy carried and made the WWF/WWE what it is today because he knew how to draw crowds and make them happy. Went to go see a match in 89, like I said I hated Hogan but by the end of the night he had me cheering for him, he made you get up and cheer for him.
2.HBK Shawn Michaels- Has/had the personality/swagger/look/Charisma, he was funny, he could make you hate him or love him.
3.Stone Cold- Man was this guy funny and enteraining. You really believed his character.
4.The Rock- Knew how to work the crowd as well as anyone and added comedy as well.
5.Scott Hall- This guy was straight up funny and enteraining.