In a castle, Cinderella's mice friends Gus and Jaq race to a chamber where the Fairy Godmother is reading the story of Cinderella to the other mice. Much to their disappointment, Gus and Jaq arrive just as the Fairy Godmother has finished the story. With the Fairy Godmother's help, the mice set off to make a new book to narrate what happens after the Happily Ever After, by stringing three segments of stories together into one narrative. In "Aim To Please" Cinderella is placed in charge of the castle balls but the prince decides to make changes to how they are run. In "Tall Tail" the fairy godmother turns Jaq the mouse human so he can help Cinderella much to the jealousy of Pom Pom the cat. In "An Uncommon Romance" Cinderella's sister Anastasia is next to fall in love.