The only Silent Hill games I didn't like were Shattered Memories and Origins. I haven't played Homecoming yet.
I always thought Pyramid Head was pretty cool though.
I liked how Shattered Memories was more psychological than a horror/adventure/survivor. Yeah, you don't have the specific weapons; that's why it makes SH more creepier. The worse thing to ever feel is defenseless and that's where they brought that into perspective. Origins was a bit of a drag but I still played it and have it. Like I said I have every single one except for SH.
"I've lead you down the road to Nostalgia, now it's your turn"
Are you sure you want to delete this post?