-
5 years 5 months ago
- Posts: 4312
- Account Disabled
| timbox129 wrote: Well, as for me, which movie did I think is worse than Battlefield Earth? Either Disney's Dinosaur, 10,000 BC, Batman and Robin, Plan 9 From Outer Space, A Sound of Thunder, Waterworld, Star Trek V or Godzilla 98 or some?
Come on now, Timmy. You have to explain why they are worse or why BFE is better. Someone who likes to type as much as you should be more than happy to do that.
Disney's Dinosaur: Hell no. That movie was not that bad. In fact, for a kid's movie, it was pretty good. And I love that scene where all the animals are sitting around watching the meteors fall, thinking "WTF", and then that huge meteor strikes and all hell breaks loose. Great scene. BFE did not have any scenes that came anywhere close to being that good.
Batman and Robin:see my above post to SarumanW and Nei
Plan 9 From Outer Space: As I mentioned in the original post, this was a low budget, B-rated movie. That disqualifies it from the discussion.
Waterworld: Yeah it's bad, but it was watchable. BFE was barely watchable. Not only that, but WW was an original script, which gives it plus points, and it could have been good if done correctly. It just wasn't done correctly. BFE was based on a novel by one of the worst sci fi writers in history (and the founder of one of the stupidest philosophies in history)
Star Trek V I agree it was bad, but not as bad as bad as BFE. At least it starred the Trek characters that we have all grown to love.
Godzilla 98 Yes, it sucked. But to the level of BFE, no. It actually would have been a decent movie if it wasn't supposed to be "Godzilla". If it was just a movie about a giant lizard attacking NY, then it would have been okay. The only thing that would have made BFE a decent movie is for it not to have been made at all.
10,000BC , Sound Thunder: I've seen neither of these, but why do you think they're worse than BFE, Tim.
Remember folks, these aren't just movies you dislike, they're movies that are so bad that they contend with BFE was far as awfulness.
|