-
1 year 9 months ago
- Posts: 56
|
[quote=TheEducator]Old_school_JJ wrote: People who know me on this fourm know I am one of the biggest fans of animation...so I am just going to say it...
Doug is a HUGELY overratted cartoon show.
I understand people like it and that's great, but I really don't see what's so dang great about it. It is fairly boring, especially with Doug himself who is a bland character, none of the characters stick out to me really.
Again, it's fine if you're a fan of Doug, but here is an honest to god fact. When Nickelodeon first introducded the lineup of "Nicktoons" the first three were Doug, Ren and Stimpy and Rugrats. It's been said by many that Nickelodeon really thought Doug was going to be the most famous of the three. That was proven to be totally flase, as the crude art and humor of Ren and Stimpy really caught on with kids and Rugrats become the longest running Nicktoon behind only Spongebob. Doug wound up getting sold off to Disney and I've heard for years "Disney ruined Doug, Disney ruined Doug." In my opinion, I don't feel they did, but again, that's cause I don't think Doug was all that great to begun with. I know I am going to get some people not liking me for that, but that's how I see it.
Mind you, I am not saying Doug was the worst 90s Nick show, heck I don't even think I can consider it the worst Nicktoon, as I would take Doug over Catdog (the concept of that show always brothered me, even as a kid. I would it's been said before, even famously on Family Guy, but who did that thing poop?). I don't know what I would say is the worst of 90s Nick shows, maybe Roundhouse cause it really wasn't that funny, heck All That was funnier. But again, not sure.
I don't care whether you like the show or not - that's your prerogative - but saying Doug is a "bland" character is a really lame criticism.
He's the every man character...the protagonist, and an extremely relatable one, at that. Off the top of my head, I can't think of a character I've ever related to more. He was written with an incredible amount of depth - we get inside his head and know every thought and emotion he experiences because he tells us through the narration of his journal. I could seriously write a 10 page essay on his personality.
Name another cartoon character - heck, ANY character - where you can do that.
I don't know what you're expecting from the protagonist as far as not being "bland." Do you want him to have super powers, or save the world within 24 hours? I don't get it. Stuff like that is just a gimmick.
Alex Mack is a great example of that. She's an "average girl" in every way, except she was doused with chemicals so now she has powers.
Let's look at other protagonists.
What's interesting about Arnold in Hey Arnold? I never found him even remotely relatable. He's cool, calm, collected, rational, and never shows any depth. Nobody is actually like that in real life. Not internally, I mean. The writers of Hey Arnold seemed to realize this themselves as the series progressed. By that, I mean they started writing entire episodes centered around Helga instead, since she was much more relatable and had much more depth.
What's interesting about Ren or Stimpy? The character descriptions given for them are as follows:
Ren; He's an asshole.
Stimpy: He's a big, retarded cat.
Nothing to see there other than gross-out humor and shock value. The entertainment is largely in being shocked that Nickelodeon let them do such blatant stuff.
Rocko from Rocko's Modern Life is another "every man" character. The difference with him is he's Australian, an anthropomorphic wallaby, and he's in a show with more blatant edginess.
As for the whole Nicktoons fame thing - Doug wound up the second biggest Nicktoon hit of all-time (prior to Spongebob, anyway) after Rugrats in the long run. Ren and Stimpy plummeted after John K left, and Rocko's Modern Life is more of a cult classic. Doug has over 5.7 million likes on facebook. That trails only Rugrats (7.5+ million) and Spongebob (40.5+ million...JEEZ).
By comparison, Ren and Stimpy has only 1.2+ million likes, Rocko's Modern Life only 1.9+ million, Hey Arnold 4.8 million, Ahh Real Monsters only 23,400+, Catdog 2.8 million, The Angry Beavers 451,000+, Rocket Power 797,000+, Kablam 181,000+, and Wild Thornberries 41,900+.
|