Top 20 Greatest Songwriters

These are what I believe are the greatest songwriters that ever lived.

Alright, I haven't done any Top 10 lists in a while, so here we go. Seeing that this site is lacking music articles, I thought that maybe I'd do one. For my first music article, I'm going to do one based on all who I believe are the Top 20 greatest songwriters of all time. I was going to do Top 10, but there are too many great ones that I had to do 20. Now let's begin the countdown!


#20 - Jeff Lynne
Coming in at #20 is none other than Jeff Lynne. He was the lead frontman of Electric Light Orchestra and a very good friend of George Harrison's. His ability to write songs is pretty amazing wether it be a rock n roll song or something like "Evil Woman" or "Livin' Thing". When combining orchestrations or synthesizers into such brilliant songs, there seems to be like no limit to the stuff you can do. Even though Lynne hasn't done much since he left ELO and the Traveling Wilburys, his songwriting still stands out.


#19 - Tom Scholz
We would never have had the band, Boston, had it not been for the founder, Tom Scholz. Although Scholz is a very slow worker, the songs he has written are very powerful and mind-blowing. While he doesn't particularly sing leads, his guitar-playing is undeniably unique!


#18 - David Bowie
David Bowie is the King and Queen of Glam Rock. (That's supposed to be a joke; please don't take it seriously.) Bowie has given us quite a number of masterpieces like "Space Oddity", "Changes", "Suffragette City", "Rebel Rebel", "Young Americans", "Fame", "Golden Years", "Under Pressure" and "Let's Dance". When you listen to some of his lesser-known hits, you may notice that he has a quirky songwriting style, but that's what makes his music so great. Even though he has been jumping from style to style over the years, he's still the David Bowie we've loved all these years.


#17 - Robert Plant
When it comes to hard rocking songs, Robert Plant is a great songwriter. I put this guy on my list because I'm sure a lot of classic rock fans would kill me if I didn't mention someone like him. As the lead singer of Led Zeppelin, he started off leading a blues band, which later evolved into one of the greatest rock bands of the 70's. We really would never have had Rock N Roll had it not been for the blues! Even though Robert Plant wasn't quite as successful during his solo career, you can't go wrong with him. I mean, come on! It's freaking Led Zeppelin!


#16 - Sting
The bass player and lead singer of the Police. After the band broke up in the mid 80's, Sting was the only member who had a successful solo career. He really puts some effort into his songwriting while mixing it in with his ambient styles. When you listen to this guy's music, you'll feel like you're in another world. Now that the Police have reunited, I wonder what kind of stuff Sting will be doing next.


#15 - Pete Townsend
A famous guitar player from a wildly popular British rock band. Townsend has written some amazing songs over the years. The lyrics from "Behind Blue Eyes" are amongst my favorite lyrics of all time. Even though he and Roger Daltry are without John Entwistle (an insane bass player) and Keith Moon (one of the greatest drummers that ever lived), their band is still kicking in. I suggest getting one of the Who's best albums and listening to the lyrics to get a good idea of how powerful Townsend's songs are written.


#14 - Neil Peart
The drummer of Rush is debatably the greatest drummer of all time; he's also the genius songwriter of the band. Yes, believe it or not, the songs that Geddy Lee sings were written by Neil Peart, and again, it's so amazing how well-written the songs are. That and the band's powerful music make Rush one of my favorite bands of all time.


#13 - Dennis DeYoung
Each member of Styx (excluding the rhythm section) has their own style of songwriting, and the band's original leader, Dennis DeYoung, is the best songwriter of the three. While JY likes to rock out and Tommy Shaw likes to take things seriously, Dennis has written many beautiful ballads and unforgettable hits. It's sad that he's no longer in the band, but I wish him the best of luck with whatever he's doing at the moment.


#12 - John Mellencamp
Sometimes referred to as Johnny Cougar. During the 70's, he was one of the most unsuccessful people in the music business, but he made a huge comeback in the early 80's, and "Jack and Diane" stands out as a favorite to many. Mellencamp is a very serious songwriter, and he really knows how to make a hit song.


#11 - Carole King
There seem to be more males in the music business than there are females, and of all the females in the industry, the only one I can think of who is a brilliant songwriter is Carole King. During the 60's, she has written songs for The Monkees, Aretha Franklin, and more. We got to hear her voice for the first time in the early 70's when she released her solo album, "Tapestry". That album blew everyone away with strong hits like "I Feel the Earth Move", "So Far Away" and "You've Got a Friend". I seriously believe that Carol is indeed one of the greatest songwriters of all time, and that's why she made my list.


#10 - Bernie Taupin
We've made it to the top 10! This one, I guess you could consider a tie. Bernie Taupin is most known for being the poet who works alongside Elton John. Yes, they do make a great team, but Bernie didn't have much luck working solo. All of Elton John's songs are Bernie's poetry mixed in with Elton's music. Bernie Taupin is such a genius poet, and I probably would never have discovered him had it not been for Elton John.


#9 - Brian Wilson
Most known as the leader of the Beach Boys, which consisted of Brian Wilson, his two brothers, his cousin, and a friend of theirs. Of the Wilson brothers (Brian, Carl and Dennis), Brian was the oldest and most intellegent of the three. Most of his songs are typical beach-lovers songs, but the way he arranges them with the harmonies and all is just amazing. The team, Jan and Dean, are often mistaken for the Beach Boys, and it's mostly because Brian Wilson has written some of their songs. Even though it's almost been 50 years since he launched his career, he's still around while his brothers are resting in peace.


#8 - George Harrison
Being the "quiet one", George didn't get as much spotlight as John and Paul during his time with the Beatles. While he didn't write as many songs as the other two did, he still remains my favorite Beatle, mainly because he was the most spiritual Beatle. When the Beatles broke up, he broke out of his shell by releasing the outstanding "All Things Must Pass". Most people aren't as familiar with his other albums; he went on several hiatus's during his solo career, but really, if you listen to his stuff, he's just as good as all the other great songwriters out there. Some of his stuff was good, and some of it was not so good. His final album, "Brainwashed", was his first new album after a 15 year hiatus and another one of his finest, but sadly, he died before it was finished. All I'm going to say now is may he rest in peace.


#7 - Van Morrison
Yet another great songwriter. He has come a long way since his work with Them in the mid 60's. Looking at his discography, it seems that Van Morrison has made more albums than any other artist on the planet. It's like impossible to slow this guy down! Giving us such brilliant songs like "Domino", "Have I Told You Lately", "Wild Night", "Bright Side of the Road", "Moondance", and of course, "Brown Eyed Girl", he deserves a spot on my list.


#6 - Chuck Berry
There is no way I'd leave this guy off my list! Chuck Berry is indeed one of the greatest songwriters in Rock N Roll history, for he has written some of the biggest rock and roll songs of all time. During the 50's, 60's, 70's, and even the 80's, 90's and today, people have done covers of his songs. For the uninitiated, the songs he has written include "Johnny B. Goode", "Roll Over Beethoven", "Rock and Roll Music", and that's just a small portion of his songs. Who knew that such an icon would live for such a very long time?


#5 - John Lennon
During his music career, John Lennon has definately matured a lot. He knew that he had the freedom of speech, and that's why he made such songs like "Imagine". Other than that, his songs are mostly either about love, hard times, or are based off of children's stories. Yes, John Lennon has been an idol to many for over 40 years, but sadly, just as the 80's were beginning, he was murdered outside of his own home. Why would anyone want to kill off someone like this?


#4 - Bruce Springsteen
I know, some of you may be shocked that I put this guy over John Lennon. Bruce Springsteen is undeniably an idol of mine. The songs he has written are songs that I can listen to and enjoy any time any day, and everything he does is completely original. There is a lot of notable influence from past artists in his music, and you gotta admit that he is indeed an icon in Rock and Roll. A lot of his albums are just timeless classics. It's no wonder they call him "The Boss".


#3 - Paul McCartney
Paul McCartney is probably the most popular Beatle. Why do I say that? Well, let me take you back to 1964, and if you weren't there, than try to imagine it. The Beatles ruled the world, and girls always went wild when they were around. From what I understand, the girls loved Paul the most. Also, being the most brilliant songwriter of the fab four, he had the most successful solo career. Even though I tend to like John and George better, I gotta admit that Paul was the king compared to them; no one can do music like Paul. Today, he's 65 and still rocking out, which is kind of ironic because he's out-lived 2 of his bandmates, and he was supposed to be the one who died in a car crash 40 years ago. So regardless of wether you've got a crush on him or not, you can't go wrong with his music.


#2 - Paul Simon
We're getting into some more brilliant people now. Paul Simon is an all-in-one musician, actor and writer. Songwriter that is. His music is so heartwarming. While he was working with Art Garfunkel, it seemed like the duo was gradually getting better since they ended with the timeless "Bridge Over Troubled Water" before breaking up. Simon and Garfunkel have both had successful carreers, but Simon was definately the better songwriter of the two, since he is claimed to be one of the greatest songwriters of all time. But hey, Simon and Garfunkel have had plenty of reunions over the years, so it's not like they're going anywhere. Overall, there is no way you can go wrong with Paul Simon with so many songs he's done that just bring a tear to your eye. Paul Simon deserves to be put at #2 on my list.

Okay, we've seen some amazing songwriters on this list. Now, are you ready for #1? This one is definately the Coup de Gras of all songwriters, so I hope you're ready for it...

Behold! The #1 greatest songwriter of all time!


#1 - Bob Dylan
Bob Dylan has been writing songs since he was in college. He is a genius when it comes to songwriting. In fact, that's probably what he's most known for is his songwriting. This guy went way out of his way in his career. He started off in the early 60's, and has continued to make brilliant music from that point on. Bob Dylan's signature song, "Like a Rolling Stone", was a mind-blower with insane instrumentation and clocking in at 6 minutes in length, it was an unbelievable effort for 1965. Normally, during the 60's, AM Radio stations did not play any songs over 3 minutes long, but Bob Dylan pushed himself way over the limits. Apart from the Beatles, Bob Dylan is the most influential rock artist of all time. Like many great songwriters, many of his songs were covered by other artists. It's really hard to top Bob Dylan. He is, hands down, a historical rock and roll figure!

And there you have it. There's my Top 20 list of whom I believe are the 20 greatest songwriters of all time. Now, I'm sure that I forgot many other great songwriters, but please don't hate me for omitting them. I would actually love to see what some of your favorite songwriters are. I look forward to seeing your comments.
Log in to comment on or rate this article. You can even write your own!
Comments
    mebabyme Posted 1 month 12 days ago
    To the people suggesting Elton John. You do realize that he didn't write any of his lyrics right? #10 on this list did.
    ChuckCPA Posted 1 month 17 days ago
    Jesse winchester? You left off JESSE WINCHESTER? He's gotta be, not only on the list, but easily in the top 10!
    Chelsea Girl Posted 2 months 11 days ago
    Many of your choices would be in my top 10, just not in that order. I've been a Beatles fan all my life and went through various individual Beatles "phases." For the longest time, I was convinced that Paul McCartney had it slightly over John because of the popularity and melody thing. But recently- as in the past 2/3 years- I was *really* analyzing the songs of John Lennon deeply. I isolated myself from his legend and just listened to everything he did, as a Beatle and beyond. I was absolutely floored. Not only did John had a brilliant sense of melody, was a phenomenal rhythm guitarist, and had one of the most singular voices of all time- but he was a GENIUS when it came to writing a song. I found myself soon becoming obsessed with skipping to his songs, because they were the ones I seemed to never get tired of. I would place him at #1. He had lyric/vocals/melody over Dylan. Paul Simon would be #2 for sheer volume of beauty. And the rest I don't care the order. All so great.
    jojothemonkeyboy Posted 2 months 30 days ago
    Sir, you know very little about music. Here are some very notable omissions: Neil Young, Robert Pollard, Tom Waits, Nick Drake, Leonard Cohen, Scott Walker, Nick Cave, Paul Westerberg, Grant Hart/Bob Mould, Stephen Malkmus, Patti Smith, Wayne Coyne, The Stones. I could go on and on. Dennis Deyoung???????????
    StyxHater Posted 3 months 3 days ago
    Where is John Cameron Fogerty
    StyxHater Posted 3 months 3 days ago
    Dennis DeYoung lol rofl Are you kidding me. He and that band suck!

    Robert Lamm of Chicago NOW THERE IS A SONGWRITER!!!!
    ErikE Posted 3 months 5 days ago
    Who wrote that list?

    And where is Barry Gibb, Robin Gibb and Maurice Gibb????
    The Bee Gees is missing
    kLITTkommander Posted 4 months 25 days ago
    Where is Sixto Rodriguez?
    armdotcom Posted 5 months 9 days ago
    Good list. Might add Neil Young or Roger Waters other than that love it.
    dogwolf Posted 1 year 9 months ago
    A "Top 20 Greatest Songwriters" list that does not include Andy Partridge is deeply flawed.

    (Not to mention Donald Fagen and Joni Mitchell).

    These are three of the most innovative songwriters in modern history.
    Muzak Posted 1 year 9 months ago
    Very good list overall. I would say you have it nailed well except I would add Mick Jagger and/or Keith Richards to this list. I mean come on? Look at the legacy and the quality of the Rolling Stones material. Its second only the Beatles.

    Also to compare John and Paul is a very hard study. I would give the overall edge to Paul of longevity (fair or not), lyrical ability to John and melody to Paul. So Paul wins there but by an atom...

    Also Brian Wilson. From 1963 to 1967 he was John, Paul and George Martin put TOGETHER. He wrote the material (with some help from Mike Love and Tony Asher), sang a good portion of it and produced it. Just amazing.
    "Good Vibrations", "I Get Around" and "God Only Knows" alone are more than most super stars have done in their whole career. Just listen to the movements and the vocals. And he only had one good ear! (he was almost deaf in his one ear) - never heard true stereo.

    My top 10 would be as follows:

    1. Dylan
    2. Paul McCartney
    3. John Lennon
    4. Brian Wilson
    5. Paul Simon
    6. Bruce Springsteen
    7. Chuck Berry
    8. Keith Richards
    9. Peter Townsend
    10. Elton John
    kookadams Posted 11 months 15 days ago
    You are correct Brian single handedly did what McCartney, Lennon and George Martin put together "tried" to do.

    The REAL Top Ten:

    1) Brian Wilson
    2) Dee Dee Ramone
    3) Phil Spector
    4) Chuck Berry
    5) Jan Berry
    6) Randy Newman
    7) Ellie Greenwich
    8) Bob Gaudio
    9) Mike Watt
    10) Greg Ginn

    I want to hear what people think of my list-
    [email protected]
    URL- facebook.com/kookadams
    kookadams Posted 11 months 15 days ago
    I don't know why number 8, made that face but whatever,
    ChuckCPA Posted 1 month 17 days ago
    Remove Mike Watt, insert Jesse Winchester at 3 or 4, put Van Morrison in your top 5, and I agree with your list.
    LipstickAndVodka Posted 2 years 3 months ago
    I love so many of your selections! Awesome list. There are certain people i would have added- Leonard Cohen, John Prine, Laura Nyro, Lucinda Williams, Neil Young, amongst them. Also, I will very kindly and respectfully disagree with your placement of John Lennon. In my list, he would absolutely be number 1. I'm not very fond of the way John's solo music is overlooked because he wasn't as commercially successful as Paul. Does commercial success indicate superiority? Bob Dylan, on his own, didn't have much commercial success. Often times I feel the greatest, most beautiful songs are overlooked, overshadowed by these really catchy/hooky tunes that may catch your attention and then leave you cold after a while. Although Paul McCartney has written many songs I adore, the majority of his solo music is exactly as I described: it just leaves me cold, bored, annoyed after a while. I didn't agree with your statement that Beatles fans go for the "music" and then you listed a bunch of overplayed Paul-penned Beatles songs. Some of them are pretty but, really, if you take the best 20 of Paul's Beatles or solo tunes and put them up against the best 20 of John's no one can deny that John owns.

    I may sound over-sensitive about this matter. I really am not. I actually don't have a favorite Beatle. I look at music for how it moves me- words, music, and delivery. I have so many artists' music that I love but I am not a Lennon vs. McCartney person. I just don't care for arguments that bring up commercial success/radio airplay as the major indication of songwriting superiority. It just irks me, but your list is great. I don't want to attack you. I love all these artists, and I am grateful for your recognition of the beauty that is Paul Simon's music. He'd be my number 2.

    Though I love and appreciate Dylan and own everything he has ever made, the three components that I care most about a song: lyrics AND music AND delivery just don't pack the same punch as Lennon in comparison for me. I don't care how dead the latter is, he still wins for me.

    Thanks.
    kevint1064 Posted 2 years 4 months ago
    I must admit I'm biased because of my infatuation with PF but I have seen Roger Waters referred to as one of the great songwriters of all time. He is currently touring with sold out shows around the world with songs he wrote 30yrs ago!
    sonsofgeorges Posted 2 years 6 months ago
    Oh, and you most definitely got the Beatles in the right order. Anyone who says otherwise is a retard. John Lennon was an entertainer and a political activist with a righteous soul. Paul was a musician to the core. And don't stop posting music shit either, you obviously got people interested.
    sonsofgeorges Posted 2 years 6 months ago
    Neil Young is a horrible omission. Much respect to your top 9 but Neil at least bumps Bernie Taupin. Rocketman his ass up to #11. I agree with the last post, Leonard Cohen should be on there, too. And probably Joni Mitchell. As far as where these additions would fit - Sting is a poser, he has no place on this list. Sorry. Not sure about the 80's rock dudes either. Anyway, thanks for putting this out there and keeping the conversation alive.
    dsrobinette Posted 2 years 6 months ago
    only omission that jumps out at least in my own personal opinion, especially considering era and generalized genre, is Leonard Cohen.
    Dark Angel Posted 3 years 3 months ago
    Very well said, jackeldan dude! The Beatles are Supreme when it comes to songs/music. Lennon and McCartney are the Geniuses in this category and the 'Toppermost of the Poppermost' as John always says in their early years. The Toppermost in the Musicmost! ^_^
    jackeldan Posted 3 years 3 months ago
    With all due respect to Dylan, We are talking about songs, not lyrics. While I'll give you Dylan is an incredible poet, a song is lyrics, music, musical arranging and all the other intangables that define music. Noone has ever in the history of music perfected that more than John Lennon and Paul McCartney as songwriters. The fact is there should be a John lennon catagory, a Paul McCartney catagory and a Lennon McCartney catagory.Lennon/McCartney catagory. Lennon/McCartney would easily take first and John a strong second. third would go to Beethoven or Motzart, Macca or Dylan after that.
    To compair anyone musically to The Beatles is ridiculous. They are in a league of their own.
    Dylan has had longevity because of Lennon's murder but Lennons catalog far surpasses Dylans. Take #9 Dream. The whole song has a dreamlike quality that totally describes the feel and mood of the lyrics. It's as if the whole song is at one with itself and communicates what John wants to to feel in every area of his song, even with the echoing quality of his voice. A Day In The Life is another example of this with is haunting lyrics and music to match. Their songs were not just stories but all encompassing events that took us a real jouney with all our senses.
    Dylan is great but more one dimentional than The Beatles.Just to compare him should be an honor. Dylan is incredible, just that Lennon with or without the Beatles is more talented, creative and visionary.
    Geno_Mac Posted 3 years 6 months ago
    Good list, only glaring omission is Cobain. Beatles are in right order, but maybe should be higher up. Nobody is going to argue Bob Dylan, well done.
    gabbleffect Posted 3 years 9 months ago
    No other great female songwriters? Umm... Joni Mitchell?
    tooey Posted 3 years 10 months ago
    This is a great list. Of course, Paul McCartney should be #1. Then Dylan, Simon, and Lennon and Springsteen. Thanks to wabbit99 for setting the Beatle facts straight. There are many who opine on the Beatles but simply don't know the facts. I have nothing against John Lennon and enjoy his music immensely. But since he left this earth way too early he has been given too much credit for Beatles music. Yes he was the avant-gadre one, yes he was the socially conscious one, yes he was the smartest one. But Beatles fans always come back to the music and the music was Paul. Yesterday, Hey Jude, Let It Be, Long and Winding Road, all Paul. He had 9 number one hits with Wings. Maybe Lennon had one with Imagine (a great song). But Paul McCartney was truly the force behind them and I am tired of him getting the sh** end of the stick. Perhaps his music got a little schmaltzy as he got older, and it took all four of them to make them the greatest, but Paul McCartney IS the music man.
    mitch Posted 3 years 10 months ago
    I'm happy to see all my picks except 3 are in there. I would change the order a bit. Hank Williams Sr., Woody Guthrie, Willie Nelson and Kris Kristofferson should definitely be included. I think Hank should be number 2 behind Dylan. I also agree with wabbit99 that Carole King deserves a higher ranking. Overall, pretty damn good!
    Trueblue94 Posted 3 years 11 months ago
    Sting, John Mellencamp, Van Morrison, John Lennon, Bruce Springsteen, and Paul McCartney? Dude, I love all of them. Thumbs way up!
    wabbit99 Posted 5 years 9 days ago
    First off, good list. I have some issues with ordering in some cases (for instance, why Carole King is only #10 and why there is no Jim Morrison). Otherwise, a solid effort.

    To nowitz: I really think you need to brush up on your Beatles before you go off the deep end regarding Lennon vs. McCartney. Lennon had some classics for sure and his highest level songs were much more important in music history. However, he was nowhere near the success as a writer/composer that McCartney was. Even if you were to breakdown the Fab Four's stuff by principal writer (which is easier than you think), you will find McCartney had the bigger successes as the principal writer versus Lennon. Macca ranked ahead of John is actually the correct call.
    nowitz41 Posted 5 years 3 months ago
    Hello, this is a great list i just got one problem with it. There is no way that Paul is a better songwriter then John. All Paul has on his own was a couple of good songs with Wings. Other then that his songs weren't really anything special, his songs got worse and worse over the years. Come on "Freedom", seriously?. Not only did Freedom suck that whole album which it was on sucked. Which makes you wonder about his songwriting "skills". After The Beatles John Lennon released one great hit after another, in fact John had better solo songs then Paul does, and he died 28 years ago. I just wanted to add my opinion to this, other then that i really love the list and i LOVE George at #8!
    n8jorge Posted 5 years 9 months ago
    I think this article is mostly his opinion, I don't understand why we're mad at him for excluding one certain lyricist. Come on, guys, don't be like that.
    dalmatianlover Posted 5 years 11 months ago
    According to the comments I've been getting on this article, I apparantley have bad taste in music. I promise I won't make another music article ever again.
    ROCKABOBBY Posted 5 years 11 months ago
    This is the worst top twenty i've ever seen! You got some great people in there but in the wrong order and ya missing greats
    theblood Posted 5 years 11 months ago
    wheres Robert Smith?
    Deidara Posted 5 years 11 months ago
    Pff, where's Kurt Cobain?
    BeatrixKiddo13 Posted 5 years 11 months ago
    Bob is the man.
    sweetngroovy Posted 5 years 11 months ago
    Oh, wow, I feel dumb about that "she" typo, sorry. :P
    sweetngroovy Posted 5 years 11 months ago
    Oh, and Bob Dylan is a great choice for no. 1, by the way. I'm surprised how many of my favorite song she wrote, but which were performed by other groups.
    sweetngroovy Posted 5 years 11 months ago
    I personally found this to be a very well-thought and expansive list. I'm veeery pleasantly surprised you added Jeff Lynne (he just blows my mind with his ability to span so many styles), Tom Scholtz, and Carole King. Really, even if you don't like the music she performed herself, taking a look at songwriting credits of many classic 60's pop songs show that King and her husband wrote some phenomenal material!
    I could be picky about your ordering, but honestly, who cares? ;-D
    My personal suggestions for aaddition would be David Gates, John Sebastian, and Barry Mann/Cynthia Weil for some great classic pop. Oh! And who can forget Crosby, Stills, and my personal favorite: Graham Nash?
    dalmatianlover Posted 5 years 11 months ago
    Oh, no, no, you're free to recommend other songwriters to me, but I just don't want you to sound like I should go to Hell for not mentioning them.
    beastwars Posted 5 years 11 months ago
    I'll agree, you are entitled to your opinion, but that doesn't mean I can't recommend other songwriters to you.
    DancePetunia Posted 5 years 11 months ago
    Ooh... And I like Green Day... lol.
    DancePetunia Posted 5 years 11 months ago
    Okay... Umm... sorry... I gave you a thumbs up. Calm down. If you write a list of your favorites, people are going to tell you theirs. That's just what's gonna happen.
    dalmatianlover Posted 5 years 11 months ago
    Those of you who are bashing my article are obviously not reading the article, and if you are, than you either are not reading it carefully enough or have no good appreciation of music. Those of you who liked the article only seem to like it because I put David Bowie and Pete Townsend on my list. Just because you guys hate Carole King, Robert Plant, Dennis DeYoung and Tom Scholz, that doesn't mean I should keep them exempt from my list, and if you think that John Lennon was a better songwriter than Paul McCartney, than you're free to make your own list. I specifically said at the end of this article, "I'm sure that there are other great songwriters I forgot about, but please don't hate me for omitting them," but that's exactly what you guys are doing is hating me for forgetting certain people and bashing some that are on my list that you hate and think shouldn't belong on this list. Those of you who have problems with my list, just be thankful that I didn't put someone like Billie Joe Armstrong on my list (I know nobody likes Green Day), or someone like Mariah Carey. You should give me credit for how much effort it took me to come up with this list; I did do my homework on this article.

    ~dalmatianlover has spoken
    dalmatianlover Posted 5 years 11 months ago
    A lot of the suggested songwriters I've never heard of. I am aware that I forgot Phil Collins, Neil Young and Eric Clapton, and you guys all seem to be hating me for omitting them, which I told you not to. If Robert Plant or Jimmy Page or whoever didn't write "Stairway to Heaven", then who did? And Mark Knopfler? Oh, please!
    ToxicAvenger Posted 5 years 11 months ago
    I agree with most of them, but you have missed Neil Young, Eric Clapton, J.J Cale, Mark Knopfler...
    xjourneyescapex Posted 5 years 11 months ago
    why is carole king on here? gross.
    CartoonFan2780 Posted 5 years 11 months ago
    You also forgot to mention Phil Collins.
    Finkbone Posted 5 years 11 months ago
    I have an issue with #17 (Robert Plant). A hell of a lot of Zeppelin songs were plagiarized. Tommy Scholz & Dennis DeYoung.....Give me a break. Most this list is pretty well thought out but some of the selections are lame. The writing is pretty so-so too.
    RetroBen81 Posted 5 years 11 months ago
    Haven't you forgotten about Mick Jagger of the Rolling Stones, Roger Hodgson of Supertramp, Kerry Livgren of Kansas, and Robert Smith of The Cure, among others???
    roguepenguin89 Posted 5 years 11 months ago
    no, you suck ass scj1488.. solid list except john lennon should be in front of paul mccartney.
    alain Posted 5 years 11 months ago
    You certainly have old school taste, my friend; but great list! David Bowie is the master! He has changed styles a lot, over the years, but that's what's so great about him! To those who dissed this article, keep in mind that this is RETRO Junk. Just because you were born in 1994 doesn't mean the world belongs to you. ;-)
    jaredpresley Posted 5 years 11 months ago
    A list is a opinion. My opinion though is artists sometimes do better when combined. Some of these songwriters wrote with other people.
    scj1488 Posted 5 years 11 months ago
    all of theseguys suck ass...thumbs down
    fairweather1125 Posted 5 years 11 months ago
    Pete Townsend should be #1
    sinclairband Posted 5 years 11 months ago
    coo interesting. um i would add thome york(radiohead), tom waits,maynard(tool)

    not bad list though. stay clear of the butt-rock dude.

    more snes articles please. thats why i visit retrojunk.


    maggielee Posted 5 years 11 months ago
    wow, that could be my moms list..
    krantzbucks Posted 5 years 11 months ago
    Greatest songwriters of all time or just post 1960?
    Berzerker Posted 5 years 11 months ago
    whoa, you forgot Raffi
    CartoonDragon Posted 5 years 11 months ago
    I know he didn't fit the typical mold, but Harry Chapin is my all-time favorite singer-songwriter. For all you youngins, Harry wrote that "Cat's in the Cradle" song. I also have to give props to Gordon Lightfoot, Barry Manilow, Niel Diamond and Jim Croce. All tops--just not rockers.
    avaitor Posted 5 years 11 months ago
    Glad Bob Dylan's #1. Woudn't have it any other way.
    beastwars Posted 5 years 11 months ago
    No Alex Chilton, Bob Mould, Grant Hart, or D. Boon? I think you have been listening to too much classic rock radio.
    Funky Guy Posted 5 years 11 months ago
    Nice article, I'll put my own list here in a bit.
    I really liked what you had to say about the Who. Roger's last name is spelt with a silent e (Daltrey), that's a mistake many people make though, so don't feel bad.

    I'm a Who fanatic, I have all the albums, loads of bootleg stuff and I've seen them twice, both shows were excellent.
    Jesus_crysus Posted 5 years 11 months ago
    No Bob Marley??? he should of been up there
    cheerfulnightmare Posted 5 years 11 months ago
    Great article and great choices! David Bowie is amazing.
    DancePetunia Posted 5 years 11 months ago
    Overall, good list. No Elton John, though... Oh, well. Bob Dylan as #1... good choice. But Lennon and Harrison after McCartney?
    Score:
    -4
    More from dalmatianlover
    © Retro Junk | Contact | Report a Bug | Privacy Policy | Advertise