The Death of Garfield?

Did Garfield die? Or was it all a dream?

Death. It is inevitable. It even happens to our favorite comic characters. Remember when Superman died?



But one question has been on the minds of comic fans since 1989. Now on the 17th anniversary of it's first printing, I answer the question, did Garfield die?

Everyone knows Garfield. The lovable fat cat who loves sleep, his teddy bear Pookie, and lasagna. On October 23, 1989, Garfield creator Jim Davis came up with a concept. To have a series of Comic strips that had no humor to them. Something more serious, that dealt with peoples fears. Hence, the week before Halloween, these six strips hit newspapers. Here are the six strips in their entirety and the dates they ran.

October 23rd 1989


October 24th 1989


October 25th 1989


October 26th 1989


October 27th 1989


October 28th 1989



The Comics delt with the fear of being alone. But in the end, the comics confused fans. Was it all a dream? Or had the Orange Tabby really pass on to the big litter box in the sky? From Wikipedia.com.

"One storyline, which ran the week before Halloween in 1989, is unique among Garfield strips in that it is not meant to be humorous. It depicts Garfield awakening in a future in which the house is abandoned and he no longer exists. In tone and imagery the storyline for this series of strips is very similar to the animation segment for Valse Triste from Allegro Non Troppo, which depicts a ghostly cat roaming around the ruins of the home it once inhabited. The strips have caused many fans to speculate that Garfield is currently starving in an abandoned house and all of the series occurring after the comics in question were insane hallucinations by the cat as he tries to keep alive, yet author Jim Davis is reported to have actually "laughed loudly" when confronted with this. In Garfield's Twentieth Anniversary Collection, in which the strips are reprinted, Jim Davis discusses the genesis for this series of strips. His caption, in its entirety states:

"During a writing session for Halloween week, I got the idea for this decidedly different series of strips. I wanted to scare people. And what do people fear most? Why, being alone. We carried out the concept to its logical conclusion and got a lot of responses from readers."

So. The question is, is Garfield alive, or did he slowly starve to death?

As stated in the Wikipedia entry, the strip closely mirrors the events in Allegro Non Troppo. In the short, a cat wanders the remains of his home, seeing visions of his family, before finally realizing that he himself has passed on before the house is torn down.

To prepare for the series, Jim Davis went around asking people what truly scared them. The majority said that being alone scared them.

So, was it all a dream, was it some parallel universe, or has Garfield really died? Well the strip first ran 17 years ago, and Garfield is now well in his 28th year and shows no sign of slowing down. So we can rule out death. The Garfield I know takes place in only one universe that I know of. So it is safe to say that Grafield was only dreaming the whole thing, and he is alive an well and funny as ever.




This artical is dedicated to my Garfield, Tweeg. He passed away one year ago. Hope you got a nice warm spot on Dads lap kitty cat. I'll have one for you when I get there.








Log in to comment on or rate this article. You can even write your own!
Comments
    Drahken Posted 1 year 7 months ago
    @mrtron: The heathcliff comics came before the garfield ones.


    When I originally saw the strip as a kid, I assumed the strip itself was a dream sequence. However, logically it is that strip which is the true reality & the rest of the garfield comics which are the dream. Denial doesn't make something cease to exist, it merely masks it with an illusion. My present day take on the story is that garfield is not dead (yet), but is alone & slowing starving to death in the empty house. All the "normal" strips we have seen since are just him daydreaming about having food, while he is actually slowing breathing his last breaths.



    ...morbid, ain't I?
    Wind Adept Posted 2 years 7 months ago
    Ah yes, I remember this series of strips. I still have the 3 pack book which features them, with Garfield Hangs out, Garfield Takes up Space,(the book where these strips are featured) and Garfield says a Mouthful. I was a large fan of Garfield, when I first saw those strips, I found it very interesting and creepy, you could practically feel Garfield's loneliness, very dark for something appearing in Garfield , but at least it has a good ending and leaves a very touching message. I came across these when I was 10, and I still remember them today. It's sad that Jim Davis doesn't even draw or provide gags for the strip anymore, he has other people do it for him.
    OPTIMUSFORD82 Posted 3 years 8 days ago
    GARFIELD IS ALIVE!
    ethnic stereotype Posted 5 years 1 month ago
    Who knew Jim Davis had a little David Lynch in him
    Blue96sky Posted 5 years 3 months ago
    Scary and weird
    MrTron Posted 5 years 9 months ago
    And if I'm not mistaken, Garfield came out before Heathcliff.
    Pizzatimefun22 Posted 6 years 1 month ago
    I've hated Garfield, he's a ripoff of Heathcliff
    DancePetunia Posted 6 years 2 months ago
    Those comics were creepy.
    Ding-Bat Posted 6 years 6 months ago
    This is sure to get an angry response but if memory serves Heathcliff is just a cheap rip-off of Garfield!
    SummertmeBrews Posted 6 years 6 months ago
    never a fan sorry. Ill rock out to Heathcliff instead'
    little_lulu Posted 6 years 7 months ago
    how could Garfield die he is a role model to many people
    he makes people feel happy
    gusto Posted 6 years 7 months ago
    This article reminds me of a Garfield animation called "The Nine Lives of Garfield." In each segment he is living a different life, nine each. Garfield dies at the end of each segment. Some lives were really short and some funny, there was one or two that were actually serious and really sad. So I wonder how many lives he does have left these days.
    Daikun Posted 6 years 7 months ago
    This is very old, and no, he didn't die. It was only a dream.

    http://garfieldisntdead.ytmnd.com/
    Daniel_BMS Posted 6 years 7 months ago
    "and he is alive an well and funny as ever."

    I wish that were true. Garfield is no longer funny. Amazing how Jim Davis could derive so much humor from such a simple concept in the old days, but now he has run out of ideas and is sticking to boring formulaic strips.

    Anyways regarding the comic strip: It scarred the hell out of me as a kid. I read it in my elementary school library from a Garfield strip collection. After reading funny after funny I came across these strips printed one after the other. It seams like any other at first But just when you think the strange story is going to end the strips continue the horror by having Jon Arbuckle come home, but it turns out to be an illusion. The comic strip has the gall to actually present the feeling of lonliness directly to the reader. Finally the nightmare ends, but it is uncertain wether or not Garfield is really alive. But I had a very warm feeling by actually seeing Garfield share affection with Jon.
    AdamYJ Posted 6 years 7 months ago
    It seems to just be a Halloween thing that took a surprisingly metaphysical and philosophical twist. Most comic strips just have stuff about ghosts, pumpkin carving or trick-or-treating around Halloween.

    Anyway, adding that bit about Garfield being afraid of being alone is actually an interesting little twist. Loneliness can be a strong emotion. Look how including it has added dimesnions to certain characters. Both Frankenstein's monster and the Gill Man (from Creature from the Black Lagoon) had certain degrees of loneliness that made them sympathetic. Or even how about the Great Gonzo. A crazy chicken-loving Muppet, but one that always seemed a little lonely just because no one knew what he was.

    Anyway, so now we know what Garfield likes, what he hates and what scares him. He's a surprisingly well-rounded character.
    shiroihikari Posted 6 years 7 months ago
    When I first heard of this, for some reason it hit me to the bone. I felt depressed over six Garfield comic strips. How pathetic is that? I guess the fact that something I'd loved my whole life had taken a turn into the dark side bothered me more than I thought it would. But now that I've agonized over it and analyzed it, I'm sure it's just a nightmare, and not death.
    MrTron Posted 6 years 7 months ago
    Oh Knites, I think the corret spelling is "article".
    MrTron Posted 6 years 7 months ago
    SM2000, YTMND stands for You're The Man Now, Dog. For anyone who would like to view it, the link is http://garfieldisdead.ytmnd.com/
    Mad Dog Tannen Posted 6 years 7 months ago
    Wow. There was more creativity and willingness to push the Garfield comic beyond it's original premise in those six panels than there has been in the past 17 years of Garfield. What happened?!
    Owepar Posted 6 years 7 months ago
    I have absolutely no recollection of that strip -- and it's been eons since I've bought any of the books -- but that's utterly bizarre and right up my alley. It seems to me like it's supposed to be Garfield's nightmare, not his death ("An imagination is a powerful tool...";). All of us have a fear of being all alone, whether we admit it or not, and it seems like that's what Davis was trying to tap into. Weird, but thank you for pointing it out, Mr. Tron. And my condolances for Tweeg... always hard to lose someone you love, even if it's an animal (and for many of us, animals are no different than family members).
    Knites Posted 6 years 7 months ago
    Nice work here. I moved to Garfield when I got bored of Peanuts. By the way, which spelling right. "artical" or "article". I'm seeing alot of people use both on this site.
    sm2000 Posted 6 years 7 months ago
    Um...what's "YTMND?"

    And it's funny this article came up NOW, as just today I popped in one of my Garfield and Friends DVDs for the first time in months....oooooooooo!
    DieYuppieScum Posted 6 years 7 months ago
    I always saw this series to be a "rip van winkle" type plot only a lttle darker... I don't think he died.
    Cutsman Posted 6 years 7 months ago
    Wow. Im kinda shocked. I never knew about this, but it's great!
    MrTron Posted 6 years 7 months ago
    Davisrocks: Yes this was covred on YTMND as well.
    Davisrocks Posted 6 years 7 months ago
    Wasn't this a YTMND too!?

    Anyway it was great. Your on your way kid... adult.
    Hordak Alpha Posted 6 years 7 months ago

    A kooky and brilliant storyline. I bet it was a big shock for dedicated Garfield readers when this happened. I bet many of them thought that this really was the end of Garfield.
    David31584 Posted 6 years 7 months ago
    Well the voice actor of GArfield for the Film Roman TV Series and specials Lorenzo Music; died in August 2001 from Bone and Lung Cancer, so I guess a part of Garfield has died, but I'm sure if a character remains to be remembered then they can never truly die!
    Roadgeek Posted 6 years 7 months ago
    Garfield rocks! Yes, he did not die. I don't know where people get these ideas. Nice article.
    By: MrTron
    Score:
    9
    More from MrTron
    © Retro Junk | Contact | Report a Bug | Privacy Policy | Advertise